Oxford PAT 2015, Question 15

2015_paper__page15

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Oxford PAT 2015, Question 15

  1. As the first person said, I left cos(45) as root2/2. Do you think they would negate marks for this as I got c=2a/root2 using this:/

    1. You’ve still got the right answer. But it’s always a good idea to simplify your answer as much as possible, so if you end up with 2/(√2) you should normally rewrite it to √2.

      1. the first line, why is it not Ccos25-a=0 thats how forces are resolved in my m1 book on a very similar question?
        because the object isnt moving

        1. You mean C cos 45 – A = 0, right? (you wrote cos 25). That is basically the same as what I have put, when I have written C cos 45 + A = 0, the difference being in the sign of A. Both approaches are correct, but I think there are good reasons for doing it the way I have done it.

          First, let’s just recap the bit that is the same for both solutions: because the object does not move, we know that the resultant force on it is zero; so whatever direction you resolve in, the sum of the forces on the mass must be zero; so if we add up all the forces the result must equal zero.

          The bit where we differ is, whether you treat A as just a magnitude, or as a magnitude and sign. If you treat A as just a magnitude (the approach used in your book) you get C cos 45 – A = 0; I prefer to treat A as a magnitude and sign, in which case to get the resultant force you just add up all the different forces (resolved along the line), and you get C cos 45 + A = 0.

          If you can’t see why this matters, don’t worry. Both approaches are correct. In a case like this it really doesn’t matter because it is so simple, but I prefer my approach for more complicated problems because I think it’s easier to control when things get more complex.

Add your comments

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s